Bennett and my nursing journey didn’t start as planned. We didn’t get to start during that magic first hour due to a nurse’s advice to “wait until he’s really ready.” Then, we were separated a lot because of severe jaundice treatment. More here.
I saw multiple board certified lactation specialists. Five to be exact. They did assessments and weight tests to determine I have low supply. I’m producing about half of what my baby needs. That was heartbreaking. However, I knew I wanted to give my son everything I had.
I breastfeed my baby as often as he wants (on-demand) which is usually every 1.5 hours. During the day for as long as he wants. During the night, I cut him off at 20 minutes so I can get some sleep. (Once he started sleeping a bit longer, I stopped cutting him off and let him eat.) After nursing, I supplement with formula. At first this was with a syringe to avoid nipple confusion (really bottle preference).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7f43c/7f43cd0538627b772c22d63204f1cd0ebfce7f63" alt=""
Then, we used comotomo bottles.
The first month was hard, really hard. It was also painful.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5cf4c/5cf4cfc274f3ab4d68fa119346d98a679b629777" alt="how breastfeeding really looks at the beginning"
Typically it was only painful when he first latched on because we worked hard on getting a good latch, but it still didn’t feel great. (It did start being easier around 2 months.)
Then there were the challenges:
- Sleepy jaundice baby – I’d have to wake him constantly while nursing
- Fussy – he gets frustrated during letdown and then when I run out of milk so he whips his head around – again, painful
- Not enough milk – this meant pumping and herbs and lactation specialists for me
- Learning to latch – standard challenge for all breastfeeding mommies and babies
To try to increase my supply, the lactation specialists prescribed I:
- Feed on-demand around the clock
- Feed both sides each time
- Take fenugreek and brewers yeast
- Pump after every feeding for 20 minutes
- Supplement with formula as needed
This plan was literally sucking the life out of me. So, after a month, my husband and I modified it:
- Feed on-demand around the clock but try to keep night feedings under 30 minutes
- Feed on both sides
- Take fenugreek and brewers yeast
- Pump after daytime feedings for 10-20 minutes
- Supplement with formula
After a month, the lactation specialist confirmed I was producing more but my baby’s appetite increased too, so, I was still at about half what he needed. She told me to keep with the plan.
To stay alive, at around two months, I started the following:
- Feed on-demand around the clock but try to keep night feedings under 30 minutes. If I had someone here to help, I would nap after nursing for up to 3 hours and let them give him a bottle of formula while I slept
- Feed on both sides
- Take fenugreek and brewers yeast
- Pump if my baby had not eaten in an hour and was sleeping soundly – this was always a gamble
- Supplement with formula
If I had listened to the books, the online forums, and the breastfeeding groups, I would have just breastfed on-demand as much as my baby wanted. That should have increased my milk and given him everything he needed. That is all true if my body worked properly. However, I have low supply. So, I would have starved my baby.
Not being able to exclusively breastfeed like I planned killed me. However, I know I’m doing what is best for my baby. Getting support from lactation consultations at the beginning is key for a good latch and to identify any problems early on. If you do have low-supply, morn the loss of your breastfeeding dream, but do what is best for you, your baby, and your family.
Fed is best.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/66a22/66a222f5e26854203b3142c394944e1416287df2" alt="handwriting-fonts"